Upcoming Event
Missouri Lawyers Awards
Kallie Cox//February 3, 2026//
State’s highest court rules against HOA in solar panel battle
The Missouri Supreme Court building. (Photo: USA TODAY Network via Reuters Connect)
Kallie Cox//February 3, 2026//
The Missouri Supreme Court decided that the Circuit Court of Greene County erred when it refused to invalidate a now forbidden covenant barring solar panels in a subdivision.
Homeowners Colleen Eikmeier and William Love purchased a lot in a subdivision in the county that was subject to a ban on solar panels. But, shortly after purchasing the lot, the legislature enacted a law outlawing covenants that limited or prohibited solar panels.
The homeowners brought their case against the Granite Springs Home Owners Association, seeking declaratory and injunctive relief and a declaration that the covenant violated state statute, according to the court.
Greene County Judge Daniel R. Wichmer denied the plaintiff’s request for relief, arguing that the statute could not apply to pre-existing covenants. The homeowners appealed, and the state supreme court wrote in its opinion that the lower court erred and reversed the decision in favor of Eikmeier and Love.
The plaintiffs raised two points in their appeal.
“First, they argue the circuit court erred in determining section 442.404.3 applies prospectively in the narrow manner found by the court,” Judge Robin Ransom wrote on behalf of the court. “Second, they contend the circuit court erred in analyzing retrospectivity.”
Ransom argued that the law applies to all covenants, including those in existence before the statute’s effective date.
“Consequently, it applies to the covenant the homeowners challenged,” Ransom wrote.
Another issue that arose in the case was the HOA’s prohibition on street facing solar panels and whether this rule could be enforced.
The amended statute allowing solar panels “expressly contemplates reasonable rules regarding the placement of solar panels.”
The lower court’s opinion focused on whether the covenant was retroactively invalidated by the statute, not on whether the HOA’s prohibition on street facing panels could be enforced. But the court did acknowledge that the plaintiffs presented evidence showing placing panels on non-street facing portions of their roof would increase the cost and decrease the efficiency of the system, according to court documents.
Conversely, the HOA did not offer evidence to disprove these claims.
Because the HOA’s rule adversely impacts the cost and efficiency of the panels, it cannot be enforced, the court determined.
“Pursuant to Rule 84.14, this court enters judgment in the homeowners’ favor. The HOA’s restriction prohibiting solar panels cannot be enforced,” Ransom wrote. “Moreover, the HOA’s rule prohibiting placement of solar panels on street-facing rooflines has been shown to adversely affect the cost or efficiency of the device. That rule cannot be enforced against the homeowners.”
The case is Colleen Eikmeier and William Love v. Granite Springs Homeowners Association, Case no. SC101152.
Share this!
The Missouri Supreme Court disbarred a Kansas City attorney for misappropriating client funds and engaging in […]
February 2, 2026
The Missouri Supreme Court unanimously invalidated SB22, ruling the ballot measure law unconstitutional for vi[…]
January 30, 2026
The appeals court reversed an insurer win in an underinsured motorist case, finding policy language ambiguous […]
January 30, 2026
The Missouri Supreme Court ruled that homeowners associations cannot prohibit solar panels on existing homes, […]
January 29, 2026
Missouri Republicans boycotted the State of the Judiciary address, protesting the state Supreme Court’s strike[…]
January 28, 2026
The 8th Circuit Court reversed a preliminary injunction favoring Choreo, LLC, ruling no irreparable harm was s[…]
January 27, 2026
Sign up for your daily digest of MLM News.
In this latest edition of The POWER List, we examine the most powerful attorneys in appellate law.
Our In-House/General Counsel POWER List spotlights those who consistently excel in the legal departm[…]
This section blends attributes of Missouri Lawyers Media’s monthly POWER Lists and its annual rank[…]
At the end of the year, our editorial team reviewed hundreds of Power profiles published in the prev[…]
The summit and awards are designed for law firm leaders, legal operations professionals, in-house co[…]
In this series of profiles, we’ll take you on a journey through some of Missouri’s most notable fami[…]
In this latest edition of The POWER List, we examine the most powerful Missouri attorneys in environ[…]
Read the stories of men and women who partner and lead with CEOs across a spectrum of businesses a[…]
Missouri Lawyers Media provides 24/7 legal news coverage and events honoring top legal professionals.
Get our free MLM e-alerts & breaking news notifications!
Subscribe for access to the latest digital and special editions.
© 2026 BridgeTower Media. All rights reserved.
Use of this website is subject to its Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Your California Privacy Rights/Privacy Policy | Do Not Sell My Info/Cookie Policy
This website uses cookies, web beacons, pixels, tags, software development kits, and related tracking technologies, as described in our Privacy Policy and Cookie Policy, for purposes that may include website operation, analytics, analyzing site usage, enhancing site navigation optimizing a user’s experience, and third-party advertising or marketing purposes. Through these technologies, we and certain third parties may automatically collect information about your interactions with our website, such as your browsing behavior and page views. We also may share this information about your activity on our website with our social media, advertising, analytics, and other business partners. By clicking “Accept All”, you consent to the use of these technologies and that we can share information about your activity on our website with third parties in accordance with our Privacy Policy and Cookie Policy. If you do not agree with our use of non-essential tracking technologies, please click “Reject All.” You may opt out of certain non-essential technologies by clicking “Cookie Settings.”
