Court rules McHenry County must allow solar farms after County Board rejects them – Shaw Local

A solar farm in McHenry County, in 2023. (Gregory Shaver/Gregory Shaver Shaw Media )
After being sued for denying several solar farm proposals, the McHenry County Board has been ordered by judges to approve them at their next voting meeting – one day before a court-ordered deadline.
The decision comes as county officials continue to express frustration with state law that limits their ability to regulate solar projects – one of the grievances with Springfield that’s prompting the county to consider asking voters this fall to grant it home-rule powers.
The McHenry County Board turned down four solar farms in December, and all the affected developers filed suit over the denials.
For all of those projects, the courts have ordered the board to revote on the proposals – and to pass them. A different farm turned down in January also must be approved.
According to court records, McHenry County must approve conditional-use permits for the Pebble Solar project near McHenry and the Water Locust Solar project near Johnsburg.
The court order stipulates the county has to approve the projects by July 22. The County Board has its next regular meeting July 21. The board previously turned down the farms, which triggered the lawsuit.
The two projects have the same parent company and shared a lawsuit.
The county also was sued separately by Arena Topaz Solar, which was turned down in December. The developer wants to build a solar farm near McHenry. Arena Topaz has the same attorney as the other lawsuit, and the county is also required to approve a permit for that solar farm by July 22.
The attorney for Pebble, Water Locust and Arena Topaz said he was not authorized to comment on the cases.
County Board Chair Mike Buehler, R-Crystal Lake, said in a statement Thursday that the board “is deeply committed to the health, safety and well-being of our residents and has demonstrated this commitment by pursuing resident concerns about solar facility permits through the court system.”
Despite the court forcing the County Board to take U-turns on projects it had voted down, Buehler credited the McHenry County State’s Attorney’s Office, which represents the County Board in lawsuits, because it “secured concessions from solar facility petitioners in an effort to address the community’s concerns.”
He said the concessions “vary by case,” but include soil testing, fees for permitting expenses, tree preservation efforts and increased vegetation and screening requirements.
The McHenry County Board continues to pursue avenues to increase local control, but state legislation “limits counties’ ability to properly regulate solar facilities.”
Another developer that was turned down in December, Crystal Lake Solar, had a lawsuit against the county, but that was resolved late Thursday. The court order in that case also requires the county to approve the facility before July 22. An attorney for Crystal Lake Solar was not immediately available Friday.
McHenry County faced yet another lawsuit from Railway Solar, which sought to build a solar farm near Union and was turned down in January. The county must approve a conditional-use permit for that farm, according to a court order. An attorney for Railway Solar was not available for comment Thursday.
The county has faced legal challenges from solar developers before. McHenry County has previously been sued over regulations placed on solar farms that solar developers said were tighter than what state law allowed. The County Board walked back the restrictions in early 2024 in response to the lawsuit, which was dropped.
Solar farms have long been a source of frustration for McHenry County Board members, who’ve said they feel they must approve the farms in light of state law that has limited the county’s ability to regulate such projects.
In light of frustrations with Springfield, especially surrounding solar farms, McHenry County officials are considering whether to ask voters in the November election to grant the county home rule powers. County Board member Joe Gottemoller, R-Crystal Lake, said in a county committee meeting Wednesday solar farms were not the only issue, but they were the “trigger.”
Claire O'Brien is a reporter who focuses on Huntley, Lake in the Hills, Woodstock, Marengo and the McHenry County Board. Feel free to email her at cobrien@shawmedia.com.

source

This entry was posted in Renewables. Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply