Solar projects are often judged by the carbon they save. New Wharton research argues they should also be judged by the social costs they leave behind.
Witold Henisz
Seb Murray
Renewable energy projects are meant to deliver a rare win-win: the slashing of carbon emissions and simultaneous improvement of lives. But fresh research from Wharton management professor Witold Henisz finds that solar projects can fuel violent conflict in fragile states, putting both local communities and perhaps even the green transition at risk.
According to the paper, “From Green to Red: New Energy Projects and Violent Conflict in Fragile Contexts,” published recently in the Journal of Business Ethics, the introduction of a large-scale solar project is linked with a 144% increase in the average number of conflict-related deaths. But crucially, such projects have no comparable effect in more stable countries.
The researchers — who include Anne Jamison of Copenhagen Business School, Brian Ganson of Stellenbosch Business School, and Joseph Bettles of the non-profit Mærsk Mc-Kinney Møller Center for Zero Carbon Shipping — tracked major solar developments across 104 fragile countries between 1994 and 2020, comparing local conflict before and after such projects kicked off.
“Fragile” countries are those classified as being in a state of “alert” or “warning” on the Fragile States Index, which includes Afghanistan, the Democratic Republic of the Congo, Sudan, and Yemen.
Henisz, who is vice dean of the Impact, Value, and Sustainable Business Initiative, said: “Building out more industrial grade solar is critical for the climate transition, but we cannot pretend that intensive use of land and water, as required for solar, doesn’t have broader consequences beyond the carbon.”
“We shouldn’t separate the environmental benefits from the social impact.”— Witold Henisz
Why Good Projects Go Wrong
But why does this happen? The violence appears to stem from souring relations between local communities and “elites,” suggesting large solar projects can undermine social cohesion. The study links the arrival of such a project to a 37.4% plunge in local sentiment toward elites, or those with political and economic power.
“We shouldn’t separate the environmental benefits from the social impact,” said Henisz.
But the consequences run far deeper. The rise in conflict can also stall development, undermine the technical and financial viability of renewable projects, and so even put the green transition at risk. “The exciting win-win scenario can easily enough become a depressing lose-lose,” the researchers wrote.
And what’s more, their findings are probably just the tip of the iceberg. They measure only conflict-related deaths, not the protests, riots, human rights violations, or broader political and economic fallout that often accompany large-scale projects.
To avoid all that, Henisz’s advice to companies is to get out of the boardroom and speak to the people who will live with the consequences of a project. Then he recommends that they focus fully on the issues those communities actually care about. “If water is the concern, don’t try to win people over by talking about job creation,” he said. “That’s not helpful.”
“It often takes more time and more upfront money. But that’s a project that’s ultimately on time and on budget. And you achieve the carbon benefits you set out to deliver.”— Witold Henisz
The Missing Risk
With that in mind, the researchers believe the green transition is being assessed through far too narrow a lens, and that renewable energy projects should be judged on their full economic, social, and political impact, not simply on the carbon they save or the capital they attract.
The paper argues that conflict risk assessment should also be built into the planning, financing, and monitoring of green energy projects — not, as is all too often the case, underestimated or downplayed.
The irony, Henisz said, is that accelerating the clean energy transition sometimes means slowing projects down until communities fully back it, or work towards a compromise that all stakeholders can live with.
“It often takes more time and more upfront money. But that’s a project that’s ultimately on time and on budget. And you achieve the carbon benefits you set out to deliver,” said Henisz.
The “de-risking” agenda — aimed at making renewable energy projects more attractive to private investors — has become too one-sided, focusing on cutting risks for investors while overlooking those faced by the communities living alongside the projects.
Financing should not receive “green” certification unless conflict risks have also been properly assessed, the paper says.
That also has implications for policymakers. “Towards the end of the Biden administration there was a big push for development banks to back large solar projects, rather than thinking hard enough about the political and social risks,” Henisz said.
But in many places a network of smaller solar developments may prove politically easier to deliver than a single flagship scheme, even if they appear less efficient on paper. As Henisz said, “We need to give those concerns a much bigger voice.”
Comments
But why does this happen? The violence appears to stem from souring relations between local communities and “elites,” suggesting large solar projects can undermine social cohesion. The study links the arrival of such a project to a 37.4% plunge in local sentiment toward elites, or those with political and economic power.
“We shouldn’t separate the environmental benefits from the social impact,” said Henisz.
But the consequences run far deeper. The rise in conflict can also stall development, undermine the technical and financial viability of renewable projects, and so even put the green transition at risk. “The exciting win-win scenario can easily enough become a depressing lose-lose,” the researchers wrote.
And what’s more, their findings are probably just the tip of the iceberg. They measure only conflict-related deaths, not the protests, riots, human rights violations, or broader political and economic fallout that often accompany large-scale projects.
To avoid all that, Henisz’s advice to companies is to get out of the boardroom and speak to the people who will live with the consequences of a project. Then he recommends that they focus fully on the issues those communities actually care about. “If water is the concern, don’t try to win people over by talking about job creation,” he said. “That’s not helpful.”
“It often takes more time and more upfront money. But that’s a project that’s ultimately on time and on budget. And you achieve the carbon benefits you set out to deliver.”— Witold Henisz
The Missing Risk
With that in mind, the researchers believe the green transition is being assessed through far too narrow a lens, and that renewable energy projects should be judged on their full economic, social, and political impact, not simply on the carbon they save or the capital they attract.
The paper argues that conflict risk assessment should also be built into the planning, financing, and monitoring of green energy projects — not, as is all too often the case, underestimated or downplayed.
The irony, Henisz said, is that accelerating the clean energy transition sometimes means slowing projects down until communities fully back it, or work towards a compromise that all stakeholders can live with.
“It often takes more time and more upfront money. But that’s a project that’s ultimately on time and on budget. And you achieve the carbon benefits you set out to deliver,” said Henisz.
The “de-risking” agenda — aimed at making renewable energy projects more attractive to private investors — has become too one-sided, focusing on cutting risks for investors while overlooking those faced by the communities living alongside the projects.
Financing should not receive “green” certification unless conflict risks have also been properly assessed, the paper says.
That also has implications for policymakers. “Towards the end of the Biden administration there was a big push for development banks to back large solar projects, rather than thinking hard enough about the political and social risks,” Henisz said.
But in many places a network of smaller solar developments may prove politically easier to deliver than a single flagship scheme, even if they appear less efficient on paper. As Henisz said, “We need to give those concerns a much bigger voice.”
Comments
With that in mind, the researchers believe the green transition is being assessed through far too narrow a lens, and that renewable energy projects should be judged on their full economic, social, and political impact, not simply on the carbon they save or the capital they attract.
The paper argues that conflict risk assessment should also be built into the planning, financing, and monitoring of green energy projects — not, as is all too often the case, underestimated or downplayed.
The irony, Henisz said, is that accelerating the clean energy transition sometimes means slowing projects down until communities fully back it, or work towards a compromise that all stakeholders can live with.
“It often takes more time and more upfront money. But that’s a project that’s ultimately on time and on budget. And you achieve the carbon benefits you set out to deliver,” said Henisz.
The “de-risking” agenda — aimed at making renewable energy projects more attractive to private investors — has become too one-sided, focusing on cutting risks for investors while overlooking those faced by the communities living alongside the projects.
Financing should not receive “green” certification unless conflict risks have also been properly assessed, the paper says.
That also has implications for policymakers. “Towards the end of the Biden administration there was a big push for development banks to back large solar projects, rather than thinking hard enough about the political and social risks,” Henisz said.
But in many places a network of smaller solar developments may prove politically easier to deliver than a single flagship scheme, even if they appear less efficient on paper. As Henisz said, “We need to give those concerns a much bigger voice.”
New Wharton research examines the growing risk of affiliated investments, which expose PE-owned insurers to greater losses under financial stress.
The Wharton–Accenture Agentic Cost Framework (WAcX) is a new task-level model for estimating the costs of deploying and operating AI agents in large organizations.
Henning Piezunka, Wharton associate professor of management, discusses the challenges of replacing influential founders, preparing future CEOs, and building organizations that can thrive beyond their most powerful leaders. 


Sign up to stay informed about our latest article releases.
A business journal from the Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania
©2026 Knowledge at Wharton. All rights reserved. Knowledge at Wharton is an affiliate of the Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania.


