PHOTO ESSAY: Wind, Water and Who’s Accountable in China’s Renewable Energy Footprint in De Aar – The China-Global South Project

In the Northern Cape, some 753 kilometers northeast of Cape Town, 163 wind turbines rise above the De Aar landscape, a landmark investment by Longyuan South Africa Renewables, a subsidiary of China Energy Investment Group.
More precisely, it is an equity investment in a South African project-finance deal. Longyuan holds the controlling stake in a consortium that includes South African developer Mulilo, DLO Energy Resources Group and a local community trust.
The project was awarded under the government’s Renewable Energy Independent Power Producer Procurement Program (REIPPPP) and sells its electricity to the state utility Eskom under a 20-year agreement, with debt reportedly coming from South African lenders, including Nedbank and the Industrial Development Corporation.
The distinction matters: Eskom is the buyer, not the owner, and what the project owes its host community is shaped by South African procurement rules as well as by the investor.
The project feeds roughly 770 million kWh of clean electricity into the national grid annually, powering an estimated 300,000 households and chipping away at South Africa’s chronic energy crisis.
De Aar is not an isolated case: across the country, Chinese companies have built and now operate multiple wind and solar projects, quietly reshaping South Africa’s energy landscape and threading into its railways, ports and highways. De Aar, in the Emthanjeni Local Municipality, hosts independent power producers (IPPs) of many nationalities, including French energy company TotalEnergies, German developer Juwi and South African firms, alongside Chinese contractors such as PowerChina.
But for many residents living in the turbines’ shadows, the benefits feel distant. Their requests are specific. They want developers to work with the municipality on services such as roads and water, and to give contracts to local firms rather than outside companies. 
They say they have registered businesses that could create more jobs and should be prioritized. Land is a further grievance: residents say the IPPs sit on municipal land. Sandile Makandula, chairperson of the Emthanjeni Business Chamber, which represents businesses in De Aar, Britstown and Hanover, says he once asked the municipality’s local economic development office for the title deeds, but it appears they do not have them. All the projects, he says, operate under lease agreements.
There is some relief around the Mulilo Trust Fund. The Mulilo De Aar Solar Community Trust was established so that communities within a 50-kilometer radius of Mulilo’s De Aar solar parks share in their economic benefits. It has sponsored schools in De Aar, Britstown and Hanover, the municipality’s three towns, with buses and trailers. Community members welcome the support but say it needs to go further. 
Makandula says the gesture is undercut by a lack of proper consultation. “Public participation was not done properly, where Independent Power Producers come and ask the community what your needs and expectations are. You just find IPPs arrive with a proposal saying, ‘we want to do this’,” he says. His objection is to the sequence rather than to the buses: schools are the responsibility of the provincial education department, he argues, so developers should first address the needs communities themselves identify, where, he says, “we are struggling.”
According to residents, the challenges start with local procurement. Under REIPPPP, bidders commit to economic development targets, including job creation, local content, preferential procurement and enterprise development. Residents say IPPs are meant to uplift local businesses, but that this is not filtering down to De Aar firms.
Water adds urgency. Much of De Aar has faced water shortages that have disrupted operations at its four health facilities. Local reporting describes three years of repeated outages, with parts of town dry for more than two weeks and many households relying on JoJo tanks and water tankers. Makandula says Longyuan Mulilo offered to help fund a borehole, but the initiative stalled amid friction with the municipality. He adds that gatekeeping and community liaison officers (CLOs), the developers’ local intermediaries, who do not understand their duties, are among the reasons the company dropped the plan.
A proposed youth center in Nonzwakazi met a similar fate. The old center, burned down a decade ago, now stands vandalized; children play there and some sleep there. “Longyuan Mulilo proposed building something big, but because of the struggle within the municipality, they ended up pulling out,” Makandula says. He says administrators within the municipality are not carrying out basic needs assessments. He did not describe a specific disagreement, so it remains unclear from these accounts whether the breakdown was about mismanagement or competing visions of what to build. 
However, in addressing the basic service delivery challenges for the year, the Emthanjeni Municipality Report 2024/2026 states that, among other issues, vandalism of water infrastructure led to increased maintenance costs, service disruptions, and reduced reliability of the water supply system. Efforts to get Longyuan Mulilo to give a comment about why the borehole and the youth center stalled were unsuccessful. 
The municipality says it shares the community’s expectations. This writer sent questions to Emthanjeni mayor Lulamile Nkumbi, who could not be reached directly. A journalist colleague attending the 16 July inauguration in De Aar of TotalEnergies’ Hydra solar-and-battery project, a joint venture of Power China International, put the questions to him there and passed on his recorded answers.
Nkumbi said the municipality is negotiating for more renewable projects, and that IPPs matter in a town where many young people are unemployed. He agreed pressure is needed for IPPs to deliver local business and jobs: “We need more collaboration, understanding, and a strong relationship to ensure that the community is the beneficiary of the project, which is hosted by Emthanjeni.” But he cautioned that not everyone will end up in business, which takes courage and drive.
Still, community members say they are not opposed to the IPPs, and they want them back at the table, alongside a municipality they say has yet to fully play its own role as a local service authority. As much as residents are aware that the municipality already plays the role of a local service authority. But it’s high time they also play a role within the community itself.
The numbers show where the pressure lies. Census 2022 counted about 10,600 households in Emthanjeni; roughly 7% were not on a municipal or regional water scheme, and about 1% had no toilet. Coverage on paper is not water in the tap: in 2024 the Department of Water and Sanitation opened a criminal case against the municipality over the dilapidated De Aar wastewater works, idle for more than two years. 
The municipality’s finances are also strained. It has received a qualified audit opinion from the Auditor-General in each of the past five years. In 2024/25 it recorded an accounting deficit of about R196 million on revenue of about R296 million, and its current liabilities (R749 million) outstripped its current assets (R420 million), according to National Treasury data. Its 2021/22 annual report cited aging infrastructure, water-section staff shortages, and slow grant spending as key challenges.
Cooperation is possible. Over five years, the municipality partnered with Longyuan Mulilo and DLO Energy Resources Group, a Johannesburg-based, Black-women-owned power producer with a stake in the wind farms, on a skills program for young people. It is the kind of joint effort residents say they want more of; whether it leads to lasting jobs is the question they keep asking.
According to Electrical Technology’s Facebook post, more than 110 young technicians have been trained, and local employees make up more than 80% of the workforce. The project is now viewed as a prominent example of China-Africa cooperation in renewable energy. By combining clean power generation with skills development and local employment, the wind farm is contributing to South Africa’s energy supply and regional economic development.
De Aar’s IPPs do not all work the same way. Leon Thulo, a security guard at Juwi, a new solar project by a German renewable energy company, says the arrival of the IPPs changed her options. “I’m normally a person going to look for a job outside, but then luckily the IPP projects came,” she says. She believes companies give back differently and credits German firms such as Juwi with transferring skills to local youth, including cleaning and maintaining solar panels. “With many renewable energy projects in the region, young people were able to provide maintenance and aftercare services for these plants,” she says. Makandula likewise acknowledged the contribution of the Mulilo De Aar Solar Community Trust. 
It is hard to say which approach works best. Thulo’s is one worker’s view of a newer solar project, while the Longyuan Mulilo wind farms have operated since 2017 as a joint venture with South African partners, and residents’ complaints about consultation and local contracts target the IPPs as a group, not only the Chinese-linked ones. Company figures are a partial yardstick: TotalEnergies says 45% of Hydra’s construction workforce came from the De Aar area, and developer SolarAfrica, whose 114-megawatt SunCentral 1 plant was built by PowerChina, reports employing 655 local people and training 80 small businesses. 
So who is accountable? The accounts point to a three-way gap rather than a single culprit. Residents say developers consult late and fund what is easiest to deliver; the municipality, by its own account, is short of money and capacity and wants more collaboration; and Makandula says gatekeeping and poorly briefed liaison officers stand between residents and the companies. Trust appears to have frayed among all three, and no single party in this story, either the Chinese, European or South African, can repair it alone. The wind farms deliver power to the national grid under national rules; water, roads and the relationship between residents and their municipality remain local work that has yet to be taken on altogether.
The China-Global South Project is passionately independent, non-partisan and does not advocate for any country, company or culture.
A carefully curated selection of the day’s most important China-Global South stories. Updated 24 hours a day by human editors. No bots, no algorithms.
Diverse, often unconventional insights from scholars, analysts, journalists and a variety of stakeholders in the China-Global South discourse.
A unique professional network of China-Africa scholars, analysts, journalists and other practioners from around the world.
Yes! I would like to receive new content and updates.

source

This entry was posted in Renewables. Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply