Workers from Jancewicz & Son construction begin work, which will ultimately result in solar panels on the roof of St. James Episcopal Church in Keene, on Tuesday, June 9. The panels are one step St. James is taking to lower its carbon footprint and to make the church more financially and environmentally sustainable.
The sanctuary of St. James Episcopal Church in Keene on Tuesday, June 9. A solar project at the church is part of a long-running effort to make sustainability-driven upgrades, according to Rev. Elsa Worth.
City of Keene, Housing and Cheshire County reporter
Workers from Jancewicz & Son construction begin work, which will ultimately result in solar panels on the roof of St. James Episcopal Church in Keene, on Tuesday, June 9. The panels are one step St. James is taking to lower its carbon footprint and to make the church more financially and environmentally sustainable.
Workers from Jancewicz & Son construction begin work, which will ultimately result in solar panels on the roof of St. James Episcopal Church in Keene, on Tuesday, June 9. The panels are one step St. James is taking to lower its carbon footprint and to make the church more financially and environmentally sustainable.
The sanctuary of St. James Episcopal Church in Keene on Tuesday, June 9. A solar project at the church is part of a long-running effort to make sustainability-driven upgrades, according to Rev. Elsa Worth.
Putting solar panels on a historic building isn’t easy. But as technology advances and regulators adapt to the growing need for renewable energy, solar may be a way for historic structures to improve both their environmental impact and their financial position. In some cases, it could also mean old buildings last longer.
In Keene, a historic church is putting that theory to the test, potentially paving the way for other historic buildings in the Monadnock Region to a more sustainable future.
The St. James test case
Going solar has clear anticipated benefits for the small parish of St. James Episcopal Church on West Street. It aligns with the church’s “creation care” goals, and is expected to save the parish money on energy costs in a time when fewer Granite Staters are going to church and many churches are struggling to cover expenses.
St. James wanted to install the panels on the church’s south-facing roof, overlooking Gilbo Avenue. This portion of the roof sits on the parish house that was built in 1899 — the primary church structure was built in 1863. The spot does not obstruct the main facade, which faces north along West Street, and gets ample sunlight.
But there were two obstacles: first, the existing infrastructure, a dated slate roof. Although solar companies are experimenting with installing arrays directly onto slate roofs, this is rare; it’s much easier to install solar on standing seam metal roofing.
The second hurdle for St. James, which is in Keene’s Downtown Historic District, was historical regulations. Many of the oldest buildings in New England sport slate roofs, and any changes to them are strictly regulated for historic preservation reasons.
While a new metal roof is recommended for solar installations, removing the original slate tiles on historic structures is not recommended in the city’s land code.
The tiles above St. James’ parish house are over 100 years old.
And when the city’s Historic District Commission considered the church’s roof replacement proposal last month, some members showed initial skepticism because the roof was still in good condition. But the solar project likely would not have gone through had the slate roof remained, said David Webb, a commercial sales lead with ReVision Energy. The company is a New England-based solar installer contracted with the church for this project.
A standing seam metal roof, Webb explained, is optimal because the panels can be clamped to the seam, avoiding roof damage when the panels are eventually replaced. Installing solar panels over century-old slate tiles requires cutting several holes in the tiles, which can cause leakage and further degradation over time, Webb said.
“If the slate was to stay, then in 40 years when you go to pull off the solar, there’s now a bunch of holes in the slate,” Webb said. “You’ve got to address the slate [damage] at that time.”
Another issue for St. James’ project was a chimney the church needed removed to make space for the panels. The city’s historic preservation rules allow removal only if there is a structural or economic reason to do so.
But at the May 20 historic commission meeting, church members made a different type of economic appeal — one that demonstrates how solar could become a mechanism for financial stability as well as environmental sustainability for historic structures.
The appeal focused on how solar panels and a new roof will increase the church’s longevity. Church members said solar panels would save the congregation over $300,000 in the panels’ 40-year life span. Replacing the slate also guards the church from potential lawsuits that come from falling tiles injuring someone. Those potential savings and avoided costs are a big deal for the small church.
“When things break, we have to fix them, but we also maintain our roof to a place where it’s not failing,” said Edie Fifield, a member of the church’s environmentally focused creation care team. “Our financial hardship … is looking at the future sustainability of this building and serving the public in the best way.”
Fifield said replacing the roof and adding solar panels is a proactive approach that will protect the longevity of the building and the congregation that maintains it.
After lengthy debate, the commission unanimously approved the solar project, including the roof replacement and chimney removal. The historic slate roofing on other portions of the building will remain intact.
The solar panel upgrade, now under construction, is part of a long-running effort to make sustainability-driven upgrades, said St. James’ Rev. Elsa Worth. She said caring for the environment is a core piece of the Episcopal faith.
Fifield has worked on several of the church’s sustainability projects.
“This is creation, and we are here to be partners with creation in all sorts of ways,” Fifield added. “We depend on creation for our life, for our sustenance. The water and the air and the warmth and the soil is important to our very survival, and so it’s a heart-based initiative for us.”
Preservation for the future
The St. James solar project is one example of work that benefits both historic preservation and environmental sustainability, rather than seeing the past and future as in opposition.
Reusing and retrofitting existing buildings is an effective, sustainable practice in comparison to demolishing and rebuilding something new in its place, said James Lindberg, a senior policy director at the National Trust for Historic Preservation.
Lindberg worked on a 2011 study that examined the carbon impact demolition and rebuilding has on a building versus reusing and retrofitting. The former has a large carbon impact, the study found, because of the emissions produced during the manufacturing and transporting of materials.
Reusing and retrofitting a building is more sustainable because it lengthens its lifespan and avoids emission production that comes with rebuilding, according to Lindberg. The building is even more sustainable when its energy systems are upgraded to solar panels, he said.
“There’s these two kinds of carbon emissions from the building sector — embodied in the materials and operating from the power that goes to run them,” Lindberg said. “If you reuse, you’re reducing the embodied impact, and if you retrofit, you’re reducing the operating impact, and those two together [is] a great combo.”
Lindberg added that investing in green energy for a building, including historic buildings, means it won’t be left behind. Retrofitting older buildings today ensures continued use tomorrow.
“More and more we’re getting used to seeing solar panels on buildings of all kinds … seeing a solar panel array on an older building, it’s exciting,” Lindberg said. “We can bring this great old building into the future and keep it around longer.”
Solar innovation
Historic buildings looking to the future will be aided by new technology coming online that could make adding solar to all kinds of structures simpler.
One example is building-integrated photovoltaic, or BIPV, systems — a solar innovation that could better integrate solar energy production and historic preservation efforts, according to a 2025 study on the subject.
According to the study from a Madrid university, BIPV systems integrate photovoltaic solar cells into the building’s exterior rather than attaching them. The study examines heritage sites around Europe, particularly historic churches, castles and homes in Switzerland, Italy and Spain, that use BIPV systems to generate solar energy.
BIPV is still an emerging technology and has not been used extensively in the U.S. However, the Department of Energy has stated it is studying the technology and is looking at ways to expand its use.
Rev. Worth said she hopes the project at St. James, and the support it ultimately received from the historic commission, are inspiring to other organizations.
“I can say that the moment that we had a unanimous ‘yes’ was the moment that made everything worthwhile,” Worth said. “I think that we’re really grateful that we’re going to be able to do this, and we hope that it encourages other organizations.”
Mason Rouser can be reached at 603-283-0725 or mrouser@keenesentinel.com.
City of Keene, Housing and Cheshire County reporter
{{description}}
Email notifications are only sent once a day, and only if there are new matching items.
Your comment has been submitted.
Reported
There was a problem reporting this.
Log In
Keep it Clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
PLEASE TURN OFF YOUR CAPS LOCK.
Don't Threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be Truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be Nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
Be Proactive. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
Share with Us. We'd love to hear eyewitness accounts, the history behind an article.
Your browser is out of date and potentially vulnerable to security risks.
We recommend switching to one of the following browsers:
Get up-to-the-minute news sent straight to your device.
Sorry, an error occurred.
Already Subscribed!
Cancel anytime
Account processing issue – the email address may already exist
Must be at least 8 characters, not contain repeating characters (e.g., 111), and not contain sequential numbers (e.g., 123).
Receive our e-Edition every Monday through Saturday at 6 a.m.
Our vibrant magazine that showcases lively community members, businesses, entertainment and lifestyle topics every Thursday.
In memory of those we’ve lost.
A look at the week in local sports.
Our quarterly business-focused magazine that highlights the businesses that power our local economy.
Thank you .
Your account has been registered, and you are now logged in.
Check your email for details.
Invalid password or account does not exist
Submitting this form below will send a message to your email with a link to change your password.
An email message containing instructions on how to reset your password has been sent to the email address listed on your account.
No promotional rates found.
Secure & Encrypted
Must be at least 8 characters, not contain repeating characters (e.g., 111), and not contain sequential numbers (e.g., 123).
Secure transaction. Secure transaction. Cancel anytime.
Thank you.
Your gift purchase was successful! Your purchase was successful, and you are now logged in.
A receipt was sent to your email.
source
You must be logged in to post a comment.