Wisconsin’s new Dem trifecta could be a boon for clean energy – Canary Media

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.
This signup form requires necessary cookies.
Allow marketing cookies to load the newsletter signup form.
Canary Media

The Democratic sweep in this year’s midterm elections has opened up new opportunities for advancing the clean energy transition in states across the country. That’s particularly true in Wisconsin, where Democrats will have a trifecta for the first time in 16 years, and which has lagged behind its Midwestern neighbors on renewables.
Indeed, Gov.-elect David Crowley (D) and legislative leaders have pledged to promote clean energy as a way to address affordability and meet demand from planned data centers. Advocates say they have already been talking with legislators and drafting proposals that they hope will advance once new lawmakers take office on Jan. 4.
“It’s very exciting to see these changes,” said Beata Wierzba, government affairs director at RENEW Wisconsin, a nonprofit advocacy group that works to advance clean energy policies. ​“The Democratic leadership has a very ambitious agenda, which includes clean energy and renewables. We know we’re on their plate.” 
Here are six key areas where advocates expect to see the most progress.
Last spring, Democratic state lawmakers introduced a bill mandating that Wisconsin electricity generation be 100% emissions-free by 2050. The bill did not advance, but clean energy advocates are hoping a similar initiative will be a top priority for the new Democratic legislature. The only such mandate on the books right now is woefully outdated, calling for 10% renewable energy by 2015. The state has long surpassed that, with a fifth of the electricity delivered to customers currently coming from renewables. 
Shifting to net-zero emissions by 2050 — including 100% clean energy — would create over 68,000 jobs and avoid at least $2 billion in healthcare costs, according to a report by RENEW, the nonprofit Clean Wisconsin, and other groups. 
Abby Novinska-Lois, executive director of the nonprofit public health advocacy group Healthy Climate Wisconsin, noted that ​“Wisconsin is really behind” states like Illinois — which mandates fossil-fuel-free electricity generation by 2045 — when it comes to emissions that harm the climate and public health. 
“We think all Wisconsinites deserve the freedom to have cleaner air and cleaner water and the [lower] bills that come with clean energy,” she said. ​“We are hearing interest from policymakers that they want to accelerate affordable energy for all Wisconsinites. We know clean energy is the most affordable.”
Advocates have long pushed for state legislation to make it easier to build community solar, wherein residents subscribe to off-site medium-size solar arrays in order to lower their bills and access clean energy. The model is especially beneficial for those who are unable to install solar on their own property.
Right now in Wisconsin, only utilities can build solar arrays that provide energy to customers. Twenty-four states plus Washington, D.C., and Puerto Rico, allow companies other than utilities to build community solar, including Wisconsin’s neighbor Illinois, which provides robust incentives. 
Wisconsin legislators have considered community solar bills multiple times in the past five years, most recently in the last session. That bill and a 2023 proposal were backed by Republicans, but Democratic legislators rejected both measures, reportedly in part because of opposition from labor unions. RENEW’s Wierzba noted that the new Democratic majority could draft a community solar bill that includes prevailing-wage provisions that unions want. However, lawmakers could still face intense opposition from the state’s powerful utilities, which opposed the 2025 bill, arguing that community solar subscribers wouldn’t be paying their fair share to utilities to help maintain the grid.
“Now with the Democratic majority, we might be able to work something out where both sides will see it’s good for the workers and good for the people,” Wierzba said. 
For almost a decade, Wisconsin has been a battleground over third-party-owned distributed solar. Under such arrangements, a solar developer owns the array that provides power to a home, business, organization, or government agency. The model eliminates up-front costs for the customer and helps nonprofits and government entities tap tax incentives that might not otherwise be available since they don’t pay taxes. But the state’s largest utility, We Energies, has long argued that this lets solar developers illegally act as utilities. Solar advocates and developers want a law to clarify that third-party-owned solar is legal so that projects can move forward. 
In 2021, Republican legislators drafted a bill meant to address utilities’ concerns about third-party-owned solar and affirm the model’s legality, but it didn’t pass. Ensuing efforts through the state’s Public Service Commission and courts have also faltered. A state court overturned regulators’ 2022 decision allowing a Stevens Point family to have third-party-owned solar — a case that advocates hoped would set a pro-solar precedent — but a state appeals court dismissed the family’s plea for relief. 
Wierzba is uncertain about the prospects for third-party solar in the next legislative session but said she hopes lawmakers will be up for tackling the issue. 
“If there is the appetite for this, we will bring the ingredients,” she said. 
For people who can’t install solar on their homes, an even simpler, if lower-scale, solution is balcony solar — small solar panels that can be positioned on a balcony or in a yard, plugged into a regular household outlet, and used to meet some of a home’s energy demand.
Legislation addressing safety concerns and setting uniform standards is considered crucial to facilitate the widespread deployment and marketing of balcony solar, since most utilities prohibit people from plugging solar panels directly into their home electrical systems. 
Balcony solar legislation hasn’t been introduced in Wisconsin, but at least a dozen states have passed such laws. Lawmakers in neighboring Illinois may consider a balcony solar bill in their fall veto session, after the measure failed to pass last spring. Wierzba said Democratic lawmakers have expressed interest in pushing balcony solar, seeing it as a ​“money-saving measure.” 
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.
This signup form requires necessary cookies.
Allow marketing cookies to load the newsletter signup form.
Advocates have for years pushed Wisconsin to adopt an integrated resource planning (IRP) process of the type used by at least 40 states, wherein regulators and utilities study and agree on plans to meet long-term energy demand, including through renewables, distributed generation, energy efficiency, and demand response. 
This kind of planning is especially important given the expected spike in demand from data centers, advocates say. Wisconsin previously had an IRP process, but scrapped it in the late 1990s in favor of a much weaker program. 
At a recent press conference on energy affordability hosted by advocacy groups, Democratic state Rep. Angela Stroud, who won reelection representing a district in the state’s far north, said she expects bipartisan legislation instituting an IRP to pass in the upcoming session. 
Tom Content, executive director of the Citizens Utility Board of Wisconsin, a consumer watchdog organization, also said he expected an IRP-related bill to pass ​“regardless of who won, because of this affordability moment.” 
IRPs help regulators avoid the unnecessary and expensive buildout of fossil-fueled generation, since the planning takes into account other options for alleviating strain on the grid, such as utility-scale renewables as well as battery storage, rooftop solar, energy efficiency, and reducing demand during peak times. 
“Whatever is cost-effective is going to be favored” in an IRP, said Content, who gave examples of excess spending by utilities in a recent op-ed for WisPolitics. ​“Utilities race to build more infrastructure if they can profit from it. When you have an IRP, it just levels the playing field across all kinds of energy sources and, more importantly, between supply and demand.”
Lawmakers could also tell regulators to require utilities to prioritize clean energy in their planning. 
“Under a Democratic majority, the legislature could decide to make carbon emissions matter more in Public Service Commission decisions,” Content said. ​“That would be the shortest piece of legislation with the most impact.” 
At least three major AI data centers are under construction in Wisconsin, and a half dozen other major data centers have been proposed. These facilities are predicted to increase the state’s energy demand manyfold. 
So the question of how data centers are powered is central to the state’s energy future. Crowley has said he wants to require data centers to get at least 70% of their energy from renewables in order to qualify for state and local tax incentives.
Prescott Balch, president of the village of Caledonia in southeast Wisconsin and leader of a successful fight against a data center planned there, said it could be extremely difficult for renewables to meet the needs of all the proposed data centers, given the sheer scale of the energy demand and the difficulty of finding enough sites for large renewable arrays. 
Utilities are ​“hell-bent for leather on building out more fossil-fuel- driven energy” to meet data center demand, Balch said. 
We Energies is building a massive 1,100-megawatt gas plant near the site of a coal plant on Lake Michigan’s coast, and has proposed a 750-MW gas plant 100 miles farther north. In October, regulators approved the Chicago developer Invenergy’s plans for two additional large new gas plants to help meet data center demand in We Energies’ territory. The Citizens Utility Board noted that other new gas plants or conversions of coal plants to gas have also been floated. 
The issue is complicated, as Balch sees it, by the fact that residents of Wisconsin’s ​“charming rolling hills and small towns and farming communities” often oppose not only data centers but also sprawling solar farms. ​“The scale of the [data center] buildout picks at so many of the normal wounds around here — the urban-rural divide, left-right, pro-labor or pro-business.” 
Last year, a Republican-backed bill to prevent regular customers from subsidizing energy for data centers died in part because of a provision that any renewable energy to power data centers be built on-site. Wierzba said RENEW considered that unrealistic and did not support the bill. 
Powering data centers with clean energy could be dependent on limiting the number and size of data centers in the state. Crowley has said he would sign a bill repealing the state’s sales tax exemption for data centers, which could reduce their total number — and hence power demand. 
Stroud said at the press conference that she is ​“interested in expanding access to renewable energy,” and noted that data centers will be a priority for the new legislature.
“Finally, after 16 years, we will have a governing majority in the legislature that is actually focused on solving problems that the people of this state have been begging us to fix,” Stroud said. ​“We will be ready to pass legislation that will bring down utility costs, protect Wisconsin ratepayers, and make sure that the public interest will come before the interests of giant corporations.” 
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.
This signup form requires necessary cookies.
Allow marketing cookies to load the newsletter signup form.
Kari Lydersen is a contributing reporter at Canary Media who covers Illinois, Indiana, and Wisconsin.
Batteries
Sponsored
Virtual power plants
Fossil fuels
U.S. regions
This video requires marketing cookies.
Update your cookie preferences to watch the video.

source

This entry was posted in Renewables. Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply